Linked Post from Treasures of Ashkenaz: Obsolete Relic, or Vital, Living Legacy?
"Obsolete Relic, or Vital, Living Legacy? —————- דרך הלימוד של הרב ברייער ז”ל בימינו (Rav Breuer’s
Derech Halimud In Our Time – continuation)
It was gratifying to see the interest in Rav Breuer’s derech halimud, which was described as “The Way of Old Ashkenaz”, in the wake of the previous post. ב”ה.
Brisker Derech vs. Old Ashkenaz Way
In the discussion of Rav Breuer’s derech that we referenced, the words Brisk, and Brisker derech, did not appear. However, there was nevertheless a significant response in an online forum to it that came to my attention, which, if I understand it correctly, believes that Rav Breuer’s old Ashkenaz derech has been overtaken and superceded by the way of Rav Chaim of Brisk.
Is that true? If so, to what degree? Is such a development desirable? Are the two ways necessarily always at odds?"
read more
No comments:
Post a Comment